GameSearch

An AI-Powered Search and Recommendation Engine for Itch.io RPGs

These games are similar to Say a Prayer in the Darkness for the Magic to Come ...
Eyes on the Prize   - A fake marriage TTRPG for 2 or 4 players
Elf Genders   - Roll Tables for RPG Worldbuilding
Vampire Cruise   - A rules-light adventure vacation ttrpg with maps, mummies, every kind of vampire, and a dance club.
FANGS - Minimal Vampires   - You are a cotery of Vampires struggling to survive in the shadow world.
Star Crossed: The Two Player Game of Forbidden Love   - A tabletop game about really, really wanting to when you really, really shouldn't.
The One   - A solo tabletop RPG about relationships in a weird fantasy city.
Pull Me From the Earth   - A romantic role-playing game for two, inspired by the music of Andrew Hozier-Byrne
BAD MOON   - a game to play with the Moon that has wronged you
abashed the devil stood & saw how awful goodness is   - forbidden love between good & evil
Forget-Me-Not: Myosotis   - Create characters from the memories they left behind.
to the moon and back   - a romantic journaling game
Vampire Block Party   - can you blend in with your human neighbors?
Say a Prayer in the Darkness for the Magic to Come is similar to...
abashed the devil stood & saw how awful goodness is   - forbidden love between good & evil
to the moon and back   - a romantic journaling game
Pull Me From the Earth   - A romantic role-playing game for two, inspired by the music of Andrew Hozier-Byrne
Alone Together in this Vast Space   - A 2-player ttrpg about space and music
Phonomancer (Tabletop RPG)   - A tabletop RPG about hexes, drugs and Rock-and-Roll - and the magicians who love them.
Star Crossed: The Two Player Game of Forbidden Love   - A tabletop game about really, really wanting to when you really, really shouldn't.
MUSIQUE BRAVO, un jeu de cartes   - Un jeu de cartes pour la pratique collective de musique improvisée et expérimentale
MUSIC BRAVO, a card game   - A music card game to practice collectively improvised and experimental music
Musical Memories   - A storytelling and roleplaying game about walking down memory lane using music
>>at least you're not alone   - A roleplaying game of romance, honesty, togetherness, and music.
Thunder In Our Hearts   - a romcom time loop game.
Reverie   - a supplement for firebrands
If you like Yucatan Tech Co Retro Catalog 2 check out...
BAKTO'S TERRIFYING CUISINE   - A Deliciously Dangerous Culinary Adventure For Starving Level Adventurers
Brave Zenith   - POST FANTASY  TRPG ACTION
Between the Skies   - Cosmic fantasy between the spheres and planes
THERE IS A GOBLIN ON THE LOOSE IN ICARUS STATION - a goofy horror adventure for Mothership 1e   - A pamphlet module of goofy and fantastical creature horror for Mothership 1e
Untitled Ghost Game   - A single session gmless story telling game about creating and haunting a village
OK RPG!   - a simple and versatile roleplaying game
The Suntouched Tomb   - A tomb bound by nostalgia and indulgence
Fímbria   - Weird investigations in the lost 90's
Shortsword   - A miserable world of precarious adventure
Mew Mew Magic   - A No Dice No Masters game about magical girls. Save the day and try not to be late for school
Juice Oracle   - A tiny-yet-complete Oracle for Solo RPG
Emergent Experience   - A Versatile XP System for tabletop RPGs!
If you like Reverie check out...
Candlelight   - Journey through the dark forest of the afterlife
Lost Post   - A Lost and Found solo journaling game about the journey of a Lost Letter.
Tales' End   - An adventure about reflecting at the end of a journey.
Spire: The City Must Fall RPG   - The city must fall.
To The City! (By Starlight)   - Its a game about being on a journey to a city. Powered by My Girlfriend
LIGHT: Patrol Zones   - A whole new way to play LIGHT
TERMINUS   - The Final Journey Of A Legendary Hero
Wandering Dreams   - A solo storytelling RPG zine of eldritch horror and exploring the unknown.
Cathedral of the Stars   - A LIGHT Strike
FiviE   - Compatible with games
Hiria: the Eternal City   - A solo journaling journey into the multiverse
Voyage   - A mapmaking game about a journey at sea
If you like Scum and Villainy check out...
Offworlders   - A lightweight planet-hopping table top role playing game
MOTH-LIGHT (beta)   - Post-Fall Science Fiction, Forged in the Dark.
VOID MASTODON - Sci Fi Forged in the Dark   - Weird freebooters in the eternal darkness. Sci-fi "Forged in the Dark"
Subway Runners   - A tabletop RPG of gig-economy metro workers clearing up monsters in a subway that dug too deep.
BLOODSPRINT X   - TTRPG Pamphlet : Cyberpunk + Vampires + Bikers
CBR+PNK [OLD EDITION]   - Cyberpunk pamphlet TTRPG for one-shots
DEATHGRIND!!MEGASTRUCTURE   - GRIND YOU UP
Songs For The Dusk   - A post-apocalyptic sci-fantasy tabletop RPG about building a better future.
A NOCTURNE   - A role-playing game of interstellar profiteering
Rebel Crown   - A roleplaying game of courtly intrigue, feudal ambition, and perilous conflict
Mona Rise Megalopolis   - CBR+PNK City Pamphlet with new cutting edge content.
Vast & Starlit   - The complete nano-game of interstellar crime & rebellion by Epidiah Ravachol.