GameSearch

An AI-Powered Search and Recommendation Engine for Itch.io RPGs

These games are similar to Say a Prayer in the Darkness for the Magic to Come ...
Eyes on the Prize   - A fake marriage TTRPG for 2 or 4 players
Elf Genders   - Roll Tables for RPG Worldbuilding
Vampire Cruise   - A rules-light adventure vacation ttrpg with maps, mummies, every kind of vampire, and a dance club.
FANGS - Minimal Vampires   - You are a cotery of Vampires struggling to survive in the shadow world.
Star Crossed: The Two Player Game of Forbidden Love   - A tabletop game about really, really wanting to when you really, really shouldn't.
The One   - A solo tabletop RPG about relationships in a weird fantasy city.
Pull Me From the Earth   - A romantic role-playing game for two, inspired by the music of Andrew Hozier-Byrne
BAD MOON   - a game to play with the Moon that has wronged you
abashed the devil stood & saw how awful goodness is   - forbidden love between good & evil
Forget-Me-Not: Myosotis   - Create characters from the memories they left behind.
to the moon and back   - a romantic journaling game
Vampire Block Party   - can you blend in with your human neighbors?
Say a Prayer in the Darkness for the Magic to Come is similar to...
abashed the devil stood & saw how awful goodness is   - forbidden love between good & evil
to the moon and back   - a romantic journaling game
Pull Me From the Earth   - A romantic role-playing game for two, inspired by the music of Andrew Hozier-Byrne
Alone Together in this Vast Space   - A 2-player ttrpg about space and music
Phonomancer (Tabletop RPG)   - A tabletop RPG about hexes, drugs and Rock-and-Roll - and the magicians who love them.
Star Crossed: The Two Player Game of Forbidden Love   - A tabletop game about really, really wanting to when you really, really shouldn't.
MUSIQUE BRAVO, un jeu de cartes   - Un jeu de cartes pour la pratique collective de musique improvisée et expérimentale
MUSIC BRAVO, a card game   - A music card game to practice collectively improvised and experimental music
Musical Memories   - A storytelling and roleplaying game about walking down memory lane using music
>>at least you're not alone   - A roleplaying game of romance, honesty, togetherness, and music.
Thunder In Our Hearts   - a romcom time loop game.
Reverie   - a supplement for firebrands
Grinderbin's Mobile Market of Ridiculous Magic Items   - 120+ quirky, magical, low-powered items for tabletop RPGs to encourage creativing thinking without breaking the game
APOCALYPSE FRAME   - An Illuminated Mecha RPG.
Courier   - A solo exploration RPG about delivering cargo across a post-apocalyptic wasteland.
Penicillin Issue #3   - The third issue of the World's Other Only RPG Zine
Tending: A Game of Devotion   - a mixed-media religion-building journalling ttrpg
Campfire | An Elegant Travel System for 5E   - Campfire gives you meaningful travel in 5E without getting in the way of you game.
The Strategic Review: Issue 1   - The world's first issue of the world's first RPG zine!
Penicillin Issue #4   - Issue #4 of the World's Biggest Zine
Worlds Without Master Issue 3   - A PDF magazine of sword & sorcery tales, games, and comics. Includes Swords Without Master!
The Teapot: Fully Steeped   - a Lost & Found game about a Magical Teapot and its journey across the eras!
Slayers   - Monster hunting in a cursed city.
LUMEN   - Build action packed, illuminated RPGs
If you like The Day the Diner Disappeared check out...
Fronds of Benevolence   - Duke DeCorticus is dying!
Thousand Pound Canvas   - 36 new backgrounds and more, compatible with Troika!
Slow Sleigh to Plankton Downs   - A journey to the glaciated world of Mora's Misstep
Parselings Core Rulebook (PDF)   - Parselings is a modern Deck building Tabletop RPG about using collaborative word magic and discovering your place in it.
Seven Intelligent Cows - A Troika! Background   - No one is sure when the first five intelligent cows joined with the other two.
A Diner at the End   - A storytelling game about times passed.
It's Safe Now   - A short  magical trucker adventure for Troika!
A Forest God - A Troika! Background   - Play a strange, fickle god from a deep and mysterious forest realm.
Objects   - Objects as Backgrounds for Troika! Pacifist Weapons, Piles of Rags, and other exciting things!
Generation Ark   - Will your story be one of community? Or will you fall to despair?
Sunk City   - A setting expansion for ANNA-X66
The Mirifique Factory   - The Spheres are infinite. So are our Spirits! TROIKA illustrated backgrounds